‘Bachelor in Paradise’ season 9 stars Tyler Norris (left), Rachel Recchia and Blake Moynes.Photo:Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty ; ABC/Craig Sjodin

Tyler Norris, Rachel Recchia and Blake Moynes

Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty ; ABC/Craig Sjodin

In the aftermath ofKatie Thurstonarriving in Mexico,Blake Moynesdecided on Thursday’sBachelor in Paradisenot to move forward with Jess Girod.

“I had way, way, way less time with her, but we were able to accomplish so much more,” Blake, 32, told Jess, 24, of his ex-fiancée, also 32.

Blake felt he and Jess had been “kind of going in circles” with their relationship. “Everything’s pointing to as much as we want this to work, it’s not going to,” Blake continued.

Jess acknowledged “there’s truth” in Blake’s assessment of their relationship and agreed to part ways.

‘Bachelor in Paradise’ stars Jess Girod and Blake Moynes.ABC/Craig Sjodin

JESS GIROD, BLAKE MOYNES

ABC/Craig Sjodin

“He was all in and I wasn’t,” Jess said in an on-camera interview.

With that, Blake decided to leave Paradise, butKylee Russellran after him.

“I just feel like you’re giving up to easily,” Kylee, 25, said to Blake.

Blake disagreed. “I know when something’s not working,” he said to Kylee.

Blake continued to head out, feeling dejected. “At this point I just feel like I’ve tried it all,” he told the cameras. “I tried it three times and failed.”

MORE COUPLES DECIDE THEIR FATE

After a note questioning her relationship withTyler Norrispopped up in the Truth Box, Mercedes Northup wanted to figure out where things stood with him.

“We haven’t gotten deeper with each other,” Mercedes, 25, said to Tyler, 27. “There’s like really no depth. I don’t feel like you’re trying to pursue me.”

Mercedes said she heard the possibility of being in a long-distance relationship outside of Mexico played a factor in why he didn’t want to get serious about her. “It was definitely something I was scared of for sure,” Tyler admitted.

‘Bachelor in Paradise’ stars Mercedes Northup and Tyler Norris.ABC/Craig Sjodin

MERCEDES NORTHUP, TYLER NORRIS

Tyler said he wanted to leave with someone with whom he felt a “spark,” and Mercedes asked if he felt that with her. “The last rose I gave you was for me to figure out if that spark’s going to come at some point,” he said.

Mercedes saw that as a “a bad sign” of their connection and told Tyler she didn’t want to give him her rose. “I feel used if there’s no spark,” she said.

Meanwhile,Rachel Recchiawanted to explore a connection with Jordan Vandergriff, but he felt more friend vibes.

“Is the romantic side for me there?” Jordan, 28, wondered to the group. “Like, I don’t know if I can get those romantic feelings back.”

Jordan expressed interest in Mercedes, but even after their conversation, Mercedes didn’t know who she wanted to give her rose to.

Brayden Bowers, Taylor Pegg and Tanner Courtad all tried to form a bond with a newly single Jess. Brayden, 24, brought her chocolate and Tanner, 30, gushed to Jess about how he viewed her loyalty to Blake as a “green flag.”

‘Bachelor in Paradise’ star Tanner Courtad.Craig Sjodin/Disney via Getty

TANNER COURTAD

Craig Sjodin/Disney via Getty

“I do want to get to know you,” Jess said to Tanner, adding that she felt “so weird” after her breakup with Blake.

Tanner thought that meant he had a chance. “You maybe being open is enough for me to want to stay here,” he said.

ROSE CEREMONY

Sam Piccoextended her rose to Peter Cappio and Jess decided to offer her rose to Tanner, but Taylor heard his name and awkwardly stepped forward first. “I’m so sorry!” Jess said to Taylor.

Mercedes ended up giving her rose to Jordan and before Rachel, 27, could announce who she wanted to have her rose, she walked off, saying she needed a second.

When hostJesse Palmerchecked in with her, Rachel said, “I think I might need to go.”

‘Bachelor in Paradise’ star Rachel Recchia.Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty

RACHEL RECCHIA

Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty

“I really came intoParadisewith no expectations,” Rachel told the cameras. “And I made mistakes, but I learned so much more about myself.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Bachelor in Paradise’s season 9finale airs Thursday at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.

source: people.com